Reasons Not to Consolidate Retirement Accounts

Thinking about simplifying your retirement savings? Consolidating your retirement accounts might seem like a great way to streamline, but it’s not always the best choice for everyone. While consolidation can make things easier to manage, it also comes with downsides that are important to consider. Let’s break down why keeping some accounts separate might be better for your financial future!

What is Retirement Account Consolidation?

Retirement account consolidation is the process of combining multiple retirement savings accounts, like rolling a 401(k) into an IRA, merging several IRAs or consolidating RRSP accounts. Many people choose to consolidate for simplicity or to manage fees. However, these benefits might come at the cost of losing specific features and flexibility that certain accounts offer.

Top Reasons Not to Consolidate Retirement Accounts

1. Preservation of Unique Benefits

Employer-sponsored accounts, such as 401(k)s, often come with unique advantages that individual retirement accounts (IRAs) might not offer. For example, 401(k) accounts generally have strong creditor protections, which can safeguard your funds if you face legal issues. Rolling these into an IRA could mean losing these protections, depending on your state’s laws.

Additionally, 401(k) accounts might allow penalty-free withdrawals at age 55 if you’ve left your job, compared to age 59½ for IRAs. This feature can be crucial for early retirees. Learn more about how these account-specific benefits play out in our article, Traditional IRA Withdrawal Rules.

2. Access to Institutional Investment Options

Employer-sponsored plans often provide access to institutional funds, which can have much lower fees compared to individual IRAs. A study by the Investment Company Institute found that the average expense ratio for equity mutual funds in 401(k) plans was around 0.39% in 2022, compared to 0.68% for retail accounts. These lower-cost institutional funds can mean more money in your pocket in the long run, making it worth keeping the account separate.

3. Loss of Withdrawal Flexibility by Account Type

Different accounts come with different withdrawal rules, offering flexibility based on age and needs. For instance, Roth IRAs allow penalty-free withdrawals on contributions anytime, while traditional IRAs and 401(k)s have stricter age requirements. Consolidating accounts could limit access to these unique features, affecting your withdrawal strategy.

Our article Retirement Withdrawal Calculator goes in-depth on how to plan smart withdrawals for each account type.

4. Tax Planning and Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)

Once you reach 73, you must begin taking RMDs from your traditional retirement accounts. If you have multiple accounts, you can choose which ones to withdraw from, potentially reducing your tax liability. Combining accounts into a single IRA may limit your flexibility in tax planning. This can be especially helpful if you want to avoid a big tax hit in any given year.

5. Diversification of Custodial Risks

Keeping accounts with different custodians can help spread out your risks if one financial institution faces difficulties. Consolidating could increase your exposure to a single institution’s fees, policies, or even economic risks. Spreading out accounts can provide an extra layer of security for your assets.

6. Potential for Hidden Fees in Consolidation

Consolidating accounts can lead to unexpected fees, including account closure fees, fund sale costs, and transfer fees. These costs can sometimes outweigh the savings from consolidating. Before making a move, be sure to check with your current providers and compare fees across accounts.

For tips on minimizing costs in retirement, check out Retirement Budgeting.

7. Loss of Access to Employer Matching Contributions

If you’re still working and thinking about rolling over your 401(k) into an IRA, remember that you might lose access to any future employer-matching contributions. Losing out on employer matches is like leaving money on the table, and for many people, that match can add up significantly over time.

Alternatives to Consolidation

If you’re concerned about managing multiple accounts, there are alternatives to consolidation. Tools like Retirementize allow you to track all your accounts in one place, making it easy to see the big picture without losing the unique benefits of each account. You can also consider working with a financial advisor to help you coordinate your accounts and develop a streamlined strategy.

Is Consolidation Ever a Good Idea?

For some people, consolidation can be beneficial. If you’re dealing with high fees or find it challenging to manage multiple accounts, consolidating might provide relief. However, every situation is unique. We encourage you to weigh these pros and cons carefully and use a tool like Retirementize to help you make the most informed decision possible.

Conclusion

Consolidating retirement accounts may seem appealing, but it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. From losing unique benefits to facing potential fees and tax planning restrictions, the downsides are worth serious consideration. For those looking to keep things manageable without consolidating, our Retirementize tool can help you get an all-in-one view of your retirement funds and optimize your withdrawals for a comfortable future.

---

---